Friday, July 12, 2024

The Death of Aharon

Parshat Chukat

by Rabbi Avi Billet

Towards the end of chapter 20, in the aftermath of the infamous events of Mei Merivah (Waters of Strife – which includes the incident where Moshe hit the rock) in which Moshe and Aharon are fated not to lead the people into the Promised Land, Aharon ascends to the top of Mount Hor and dies. 

Aharon’s death is later reported to us in Parshat Masei at the 7th or 8th to last stop, “They traveled from Kadesh,and camped at Mount Hor. Aharon went up the mountain at God’s instruction and died there in the 40th year since the time of the Exodus. This was on Rosh Chodesh (Av) of the 5th month. Aharon lived to 123 years.” (33:37-29) Following the chronology presented to us in the Torah, this makes sense. 

But Aharon’s death is recorded in Parshat Eikev as well, in a context that meets no criteria – either of chronology or of associating Aharon’s death to Mei Merivah, which is part of the explanation given to him at the actual time of his death in our parsha, in 20:24, when Aharon is told “Aharon will die, for he will not come to the land I have promised to the Bnei Yisrael, on account of your rebelling against My word at Mei Merivah.” 

In Eikev, the death of Aharon is recorded in association with events being reviewed for the benefit of those who will be entering the land, in hopes they will not repeat the errors of their parents’ generation, most specifically the Golden Calf. After recounting that God told him to make an ark of wood and to bring two new tablets for God to inscribe upon them the words of the Tablets Moshe had broken, Moshe describes how, armed with the second set of tablets, “‘I turned and descended from the mountain and placed the Tablets in the ark I had made, and they remained there as God had instructed me.’ And the Children of Israel traveled from Beerot Bnei Yaakan to Mosair: there Aharon died and was buried there, and his son Elazar was made Kohen in his place. From there they traveled to Gudgode, and from there to Yatvat, the land of rivers.” (Devarim 10:5-7) 

Those locations are reported on in Masei (Bamidbar 33:30-33), several verses and several stops before the events we saw (2nd paragraph above) which were recorded in the 40th year. [Rashi in Devarim 1:46 notes that they were in Kadesh for 19 years, so even though there aren’t a lot of stops between Yatvat in 33:33 and Aharon’s death 4 pesukim later, their arrival in Kadesh in 33:36 explains the passage of time.] 

Obviously the mention of Aharon’s death in Eikev in that context requires an explanation. Ibn Ezra rejects the need for an explanation, simply accepting that the locations mentioned are different places, and that the place where Aharon actually died had multiple names – which is not an uncommon feature of the Torah. Most views, however, do not accord with that of Ibn Ezra (though R Yosef B’chor Shor agrees with Ibn Ezra!). 

 Taking a number of narrative pieces from Parshas Chukas, stringing them together to form a larger picture of what was going on in the Israelite encampment, Targum Yonatan describes a battle with Amalek which caused a number of groups to return to Egypt. The tribe of Levi pursued them, and a civil war/battle ensued in which 8 families were killed on the Israelite side, and 4 Levite families fell as well. They asked themselves, what caused this to happen? And they realized it was because they did not heed the teachings of Aharon, to love your fellow, and specifically because they didn’t adequately mourn for him. So they decided to eulogize him on that spot, as if he had died and been buried there. [This is brought down in Yerushalmi Sotah 1:10 (8b)] – some of this is hinted to in Divrei Hayamim in that Yerushalmi passage.] 

Rashi’s presentation explains this a little more clearly. After noting a discrepancy in the order of the travels, and asking about the true location of Aharon’s death, Rashi writes (translation from Sefaria): 
“…Go and count and you will find that there are eight stations from Mosera to Mount Hor! — But really this also is part of the reproof offered by Moses. In effect he said, “This, also, ye did: when Aaron died on Mount Hor at the end of forty years and the clouds of Divine Glory departed, ye feared war with the king of Arad and you appointed a leader that ye might return to Egypt, and ye turned backwards eight stages unto Bene Jaakan and hence to Mosera. There the sons of Levi fought with you, and they slew some of you, and you some of them, until they forced you back on the road along which you had retreated. From there (Mosera) ye returned to Gudgodah, — that is identical with Hor Hagidgod (Numbers 33:32). 
“Moses placed this reproof immediately after the mention of the breaking of the tablets to indicate that the death of the righteous is as grievous before the Holy One, blessed be He, as the day on which the tablets were broken, and to tell you that it was displeasing to Him when they said, (Numbers 14:4) “Let us set up a head (another god; see Rashi on that verse) in order to part from Him, as was the day on which they made the golden calf (Leviticus Rabbah 20:12).”
 This approach suggests that Moshe reported on Aharon’s death, not chronologically, but thematically, to present a message of behavior to the Bnei Yisrael not to fall prey to their yetzer Hara – turning from God in spite, such as with the Golden Calf, such as when clouds of glory depart, such as at a time of war – all brings about negativity which is on par with the loss of a righteous leader (consider that the whole Mei Merivah story seems to be triggered by the death of Miriam, and the inability to mourn properly). 

 Rashbam intimates a subtle hint Moshe is sending to the people. Aharon could have died at the time of the Golden Calf. But he didn’t die at that time on account of the prayers of Moshe (see also Devarim 9:20). [See here for other reasons too!]

 Ramban notes how Rashi’s comment is taken from a different passage in Yerushalmi (Yoma 1:1), as he suggests that Mount Hor was actually a very big mountain spanning many parasang (one need merely look to the east of Israel, to the mountains of Moab, to see how easily this can be true), and that Moshe is referencing various points on the same mountain range – putting Aharon’s death in a particular context. Aharon’s death WAS in the 40th year, and it WAS in Mosair (or Mosera), which is a geographical point in a larger range of mountains known as Mount Hor. The context of mentioning Aharon’s death related to the aftermath of the Golden Calf is because Moshe prayed on his behalf at that time (see Rashbam in the previous paragraph), and Moshe is talking to the people in Eikev about negative outcomes and positive outcomes that are much dependent on behavior and trust in God. 

The implication in the passage of Eikev, therefore (as Chizkuni spells it out) is as if Moshe is saying “Don’t assume or ever claim that Aharon died at the time of the Golden Calf, because he didn’t die at that time! I prayed for him, and we moved on from that time. Aharon died 40 years later, at the location mentioned… not at the bottom of Har Sinai.”

 Kli Yakar combines all of the components of the narrative of Chukas to demonstrate why Aharon’s death is referenced by Moshe in Eikev – noting that the deaths of the righteous are as difficult for God as the breaking of the Tablets, while also noting that the people are supposed to learn that the merit of the righteous carries through to the Children of Israel even after they have passed. But the Children of Israel must demonstrate that they believe that, in order for it to work. 

There are people in our ranks who are the best at expressing this. And there are people in our ranks who forget that while all is in God’s hands, our own choices and behaviors, and heeding of lessons sent to us if we are only paying attention, all play a significant role in the outcomes our people face. 

 For example, we are grateful for the incredible sacrifices, ethic, and dedication of the IDF. At the same time, many have lost their lives. How much do we attribute their successes and failures to their tactical training (which is of course quite important), and how much do we attribute to our own successes and failures (I speak of each of us as individuals, and all of klal Yisrael in general)? Do we – all of Am Yisrael – see our own hand affecting the tides of battle and the successes of our soldiers in their holy task of protecting the people of Israel, and Jews around the world by extension? 

That is part of the message of Aharon’s death being recorded in a chronological context outside of reality – to remind people that the righteous impact the world in ways we can’t comprehend. And therefore it is incumbent upon each of us to dedicate ourselves to achieve higher levels of righteousness. For the sake and safety of Am Yisrael.

Thursday, July 4, 2024

On July 4th and American Independence

 This is the note I shared with congregation before Shabbos this week - in honor of July 4th weekend

   There is something special about the celebrations surrounding July 4, which includes the reality that overall, the experience of the Jewish people in the United States of America has been a blessing of history. Since the time George Washington wrote his famous letter to the Touro Synagogue, Jews found a freedom of worship in the United States in America that was second to none in the history of the Diaspora. Yes, there were pockets in time and in different lands where Jews went unbothered, and where there was tremendous growth, freedom, scholarship, and even political advancement. But every nation in Europe also, at least once, expelled the Jews from their land over religious intolerance. The founding President of the United States wrote:

May the children of the stock of Abraham who dwell in this land continue to merit and enjoy the good will of the other inhabitants—while every one shall sit in safety under his own vine and fig tree and there shall be none to make him afraid.

May the father of all mercies scatter light, and not darkness, upon our paths, and make us all in our several vocations useful here, and in His own due time and way everlastingly happy.

The Evilness of Machlokes That Is Not For the Sake of Heaven

Parshat Korach

by Rabbi Avi Billet

In Pirkei Avos 5:17 (or 19 or 20 – different volumes have different breakdowns) we are introduced to the merits of a Machlokes (dispute) that is for the sake of heaven versus a Machlokes which is not for the sake of heaven. A dispute over understanding of Torah, such as between Hillel and Shammai, is viewed as a dispute which endures, for it has merit. Its purpose is a higher calling – getting to the truth (see Meiri). The other kind of dispute which is considered meritless is the “Machlokes of Korach and his congregation.” 

 Many note that the dispute should be presented as one between Korach and Moshe! After all, against whom did Korach address his complaints and direct his confrontation? 

The simple answer is that the real dispute was among the people who seemed to be united, but who weren’t really united. What kept them together as a group was a seeming common cause, and an argument of “all the nation is holy,” which carries the Orwellian implication that “some are more holy than others” if you’d just give the holy position to the “correct” “some” so we would know where we all stand. 

Friday, June 28, 2024

Real Teshuvah = Moving With the Torah

Parshat Shlach

by Rabbi Avi Billet

Last week we read the “famous” verse of ויהי בנסע הארון, which essentially describes the ideal form of travel for Israel in the wilderness, with the Ark leading the way accompanied by Moshe saying “Arise God and may Your enemies run from before You.” 

The idea of the Ark leading the people should have forewarned those who tried to take initiative, too little and too late, that their quest to conquer the land would fail especially after they had been told they’d be unsuccessful (14:41-42). The verse actually states (14:44) - וַיַּעְפִּ֕לוּ לַעֲל֖וֹת אֶל־רֹ֣אשׁ הָהָ֑ר וַאֲר֤וֹן בְּרִית־יְקֹוָק֙ וּמֹשֶׁ֔ה לֹא־מָ֖שׁוּ מִקֶּ֥רֶב הַֽמַּחֲנֶֽה: They tried to go up the mountain, but the Ark and Moshe did not move from the Israelite encampment. 

If the Ark does not move, there is nowhere to go! How did they miss this? 

Sunday, June 23, 2024

Some Thoughts On Humility

 This was written to honor a member of our synagogue who passed away this week, but did not want any eulogies recited, nor any kind of public mourning to be done in the wake of his absence. I did not mention his name out of respect for his wishes. 

Parshat B'haalotkha

by Rabbi Avi Billet

One of the more famous statements in the Torah concerns Moshe Rabbenu, and it appears in our parsha in the context of the comments made by Miriam about her youngest brother, in talking, most surely in a concerned manner, with her brother Aharon about their brother Moshe. Without getting into the details, or trying to understand the cryptic nature of her comments, the Torah’s immediate response to what she says is וְהָאִ֥ישׁ מֹשֶׁ֖ה עָנָ֣יו מְאֹ֑ד מִכֹּל֙ הָֽאָדָ֔ם אֲשֶׁ֖ר עַל־פְּנֵ֥י הָאֲדָמָֽה – the man Moshe was exceedingly humble, of all the people on the face of the earth. 

 In truth, we have seen this to be true not moments earlier in the reading when Yehoshua, in defense of his master, tried to instruct Moshe to imprison or worse to Eldad and Meidad who were prophesying in the camp. Moshe’s response was not only that he felt no slight to his own honor in their prophesying, but he wished more people would prophesy as well. If only that were a more widespread phenomenon among the people of Israel. 

Friday, June 21, 2024

What Effected Travel? Let us Count the Things…

Parshat B'haaloskha 

by Rabbi Avi Billet 

The last 9 verses of Chapter 9 give a number of permutations for how the cloud that would hover above the Mishkan would be the instigator for travel beginning, and when they would pause and set up camp. It gives examples of how they might stay in a location a very short time, such as a day or two, or even a month (this instruction is given before the people were doomed to be in the wilderness 40 years – and we know from other sources (Rashi Devarim 1:46) that they stayed in Kadesh for 19 years(!), a very lengthy period of time!). 

 The chapter concludes, telling us that since the cloud was the indicator, “On God’s word they camped, and on God’s word they traveled.” 

This makes what is presented in the following chapter very odd. Chapter 10 begins with instruction to Moshe to make for himself personal silver trumpets to be used “for calling the nation, and for indicating time to travel.” The first use is completely understood. It’s an ancient bullhorn, siren, megaphone, speaker-system… call it what you will, but the point is that the sign is a gathering call. 

But to cause travel? What were those final verses in Chapter 9 all about? The cloud is quite visible, thank you very much. If travel is based on God’s word, and God’s word alone, why would Moshe possibly have a need, or even a right, to use the silver trumpets as a call to gather items because it is a time to travel? 

Friday, June 7, 2024

Inspiration Comes From Your Focus – Not From Where You Stand

Parshat Bamidbar 

by Rabbi Avi Billet

Now that the time has come to move from Sinai off into the wilderness, with the Promised Land as a soon-to-be-reached destination, Chapter 2 of Bamidbar focuses on how the Israelites were to encamp and travel, with Mishkan at the center, the families of Levi, the families of Aharon and Moshe directly on the four sides of the Mishkan, and three tribes in each of the 4 directions surrounding the Mishkan as well. 

How were these divisions created – why this tribe with these two? Which group is in the north v the south, etc? 

Perhaps for varying reasons, there are different ways the Midrash presents possible frameworks for how the Israeltites were placed in the encampments and travels surrounding the Mishkan. 

 One version appears in Midrash Rabba 2:3, and records that when God appeared on Sinai, 220,000 angels descended with Him and encamped around the mountain divided by flags. When the Israelites saw this (a miracle they merited to see), they wanted to eventually travel and encamp in the same manner of the angels. God then promised it would happen, and He later instructed Moshe to set them up thus. 

This approach champions a very holy level of setup, unencumbered by any kind of debate – it is a simple mimicking of divine creatures, making the assignment and its follow through easy to understand without much fanfare, discussion, or drama. 

 However, the next two Midrashim follow a different approach, noting a connection to forefather Yaakov, and practical considerations as well. 

 A Midrash recorded in the Otzar Midrashim puts the setup in Yaakov’s mouth shortly before his death. 

 Here is a loose translation of that Midrashic narrative: 

“God, with wisdom, founded the world” (Mishlei 3:19) – He created his world with four directions, east west, north, and south. From the East, light comes to the world. From the West are the storage-places of snow and hail, and from there emerges cold and hot for the world. From the North emerges darkness for the world. From the South comes rain and dew as a blessing. 

 "Just as He created four directions, so He crated four creatures around His throne, with His throne being above all of them. 

 “And so did Yaakov set his sons, in order, at the time he was instructing them to about the four future flags of wilderness [travel]. “Per this order you should carry my coffin…” and he told them that to the East would be Levi, Yehuda, Yissachar and Zevulun; to the South would be Reuven, Shimon, and Gad; to the North would be Dan, Naftali, and Asher; to the West would be Binyamin, Ephraim, and Menashe.” 

 This arrangement assumes Levi the son of Yaakov accompanied his father, while Yosef, son of Yaakov, was elsewhere, perhaps in front of everyone, but not directly around the coffin with his brothers, because his sons were in their positions alongside their Uncle Binyamin. 

“This order was used for the four flagged encampments in the wilderness. 

 “East, from which light emanates to the world: Levi – the light of the Temple, Yehuda – the king of Israel, Yissachar – who [best] know the Torah which is referred to as אור (light), as the verse says “And the children of Yissachar are the best to understand wisdom” (Divrei Hayamim I 12:33)” 

This does not explain the presence of Zevulun, nor how Levi was encamped later on in the wilderness. This will be addressed by the next Midrashic tale – from Tanchuma – presented below.

“South, from which blessed rain emanates: Reuven – who was a Baal Teshuvah (someone who had repented), because on account of the penitent God effectuates blessings to Israel, Gad – who is a master of strength, as blessed rain comes with strength, Shimon – is between them to bring atonement. 

West, the storage-places of snow, cold, heat: Opposite that is Binyamin, Ephraim and Menashe. The Divine Presence is always in the west, as the verse says “The Lord's beloved one shall dwell securely beside Him; He protects him all day long, and He dwells between his shoulders.” (Devarim 33:12) 

North, from which darkness emanates to the world: Dan – whose children brought darkness through bringing idolatry (Shoftim 18), with him are Naftali, and Asher – who bring light into the darkness as the verse says “He will be pleasing to his brothers, and immerse his foot in oil.” (Devarim 33:24)” 

Beyond the absence of Yosef, and a lack of explanation for some of the later realities of the encampments, the above passage leaves much mystery, while it presents depth connected to larger workings of the world influencing the placement of the tribes – the sons of Yaakov specifically, and later their descendants. 

There is another version of this Midrash which presents how Yaakov came to this positioning of the tribes. The verse tells us (Bamidbar 2:2): אִ֣ישׁ עַל־דִּגְל֤וֹ בְאֹתֹת֙ לְבֵ֣ית אֲבֹתָ֔ם יַחֲנ֖וּ בְּנֵ֣י יִשְׂרָאֵ֑ל מִנֶּ֕גֶד סָבִ֥יב לְאֹֽהֶל־מוֹעֵ֖ד יַחֲנֽוּ - The children of Israel shall encamp each man by his flag with the signs of their fathers' house; some distance from the Tent of Meeting they shall encamp. 

 The Midrash Tanchuma presents a question. Why does the verse mention “the signs” – wouldn’t the flag be sufficient? [The Midrash doesn’t state it directly, but it would seem that the narrative which follows references an old “sign” going back to what Yaakov instructed.] 

The Midrash goes on to explain that when Yaakov was about to die, he told his sons that they, and only they (not any Egyptians, or even his own grandchildren who were children of Canaanite women), were to carry his coffin. The translation which follows is from sefaria.org 

“How did he charge them? He said to them, “Judah, Issachar, and Zebulun shall carry my bier on the East; Reuben, Simeon, and Gad, on the South; Ephraim, Manasseh, and Benjamin, on the West; Dan, Asher, and Naphtali, on the North. Joseph is not to carry [at all], because he is a king; and you must impart honor to him. Nor is Levi to carry. Why? Because he will carry the ark (aron), and whoever carries the ark of the One who lives forever is not to carry a coffin (aron) of the dead. If you do this and carry my bier, just as I have charged you, the Holy One, blessed be He, is going to have you encamp by the various standards.” 

 “When Israel went forth from Egypt, the Holy One, blessed be He, said, “Now is the time for them to make standards, just as their father had proclaimed to them that they were going to make standards.” Immediately the Holy One, blessed be He, said to Moses, “Make those standards for my name.” Immediately Moses began to be concerned. He said, “There is going to be dissension among the tribes. If I tell the tribe of Judah to encamp in the East, they will say, ‘It is impossible for us to encamp anywhere but in the South.’ And so each and every tribe [would act] like that one.” The Holy One, blessed be He, said to him, “What concern is that to you? They do not need you in this matter. They will recognize their dwellings by themselves. Why? Because their father's will was in their hand on how to encamp by the standards. I am not establishing something new. They already have their father's arrangements in their hands. Just as they have taken positions around his bier, so let them take positions around the tabernacle.” Where is it shown? Where it is stated (in Numb. 2:2), “Each with his standard, under the banners [for their fathers' house].” 

 The Midrash then notes the blessing of having good neighbors. Because the eastern camp of Yehuda, Yissachar and Zevulun were closest to Moshe, Aharon and their families, they all became great in Torah. [Yehuda’s success is based on Bereshis 49:10, Yissachar’s - Divrei Hayamim I 12:33, and Zevulun’s - Shoftim 5:14 – a reference to the Zebulunites being scribes] 

Then the Midrash notes the curse of having bad neighbors, since in the South, Reuven, Shimon, and Gad were closest to Kehat and, most notoriously, the family of Korach. 

Rounding out the encampment - on the West were the Children of Gershon (son of Levi) with Ephraim, Menashe, and Binyamin being adjacent to them. And on the North were the Children of Merari (son of Levi), with Dan, Naftali, and Asher being adjacent to them. 

 In his Peninim Al HaTorah (vol 20), Rabbi Scheinbaum suggests there was no debate about the placement because debate only comes when a decision is made that benefits the decider. If there is no ulterior motive, except a fair and impartial judgment, it is easy for everyone to accept. Since Yaakov was not going to be alive when his children were to escort him to his final resting place, he had nothing to gain from their assigned locations, they accepted it – and their descendants were happy to follow it into their own times. 

 We could add to this that simply being around the Mishkan is enough of a blessing. Not everyone can be front and center! But we can make the best of our lot, embracing the opportunities we have as being part of the encampment of Israel. When we turn to the Mishkan and the Torah as our inspiration, and make every effort possible to include ourselves in our shared destiny, we earn the stripes of being part of the people of Israel. This is enhanced by surrounding ourselves with good neighbors. 

 As we come to the holiday of Shavuos this week, let us celebrate our connection to Torah on whatever level we are. But let us also take the inspiration from those who are more advanced than we are to remind ourselves that we can always be growing. Whether we sit (proverbially) in the back of the room, somewhere in the middle, or even in the front, our focus should be towards our center, our core, which is the Mishkan, the house of the Torah, and the service of God. When we remember the source of our inspiration, and put aside where we are at personally, we can bask in His goodness and remember that our lives are enriched by how much we challenge ourselves to grow in Torah and in our relationship with God.