Friday, November 20, 2026

Yaakov and His Sheepish Success

Parshat Vayetze

by Rabbi Avi Billet

The first blessing Yaakov received from his father in Toldos – the one the Torah seems to present as being “stolen” from Eisav [this is a much bigger discussion surrounding who knew what? Isn’t Yaakov the man of Truth?], is translated as follows: 

 “And may the Lord give you of the dew of the heavens and [of] the fatness of the earth and an abundance of grain and wine. Nations shall serve you and kingdoms shall bow down to you; you shall be a master over your brothers, and your mother's sons shall bow down to you. Those who curse you shall be cursed, and those who bless you shall be blessed."

 When was this supposed to have taken place? It certainly doesn’t happen in Yaakov’s lifetime. And, if anything, it’s a blessing of grain and wine, not of riches through sheep or cattle. 

 And so, when Yaakov and Eisav will meet again in next week’s parsha, Yaakov will bow to Eisav 7 times, indicating that even the part about bowing is not of interest to him. 

 All of this seems to mean that Yaakov took the blessing because his mother told him to, but as far as seeing it for anything more than words… maybe he did, but maybe he did not. 

 And if, by chance, he did not, then after the birth of Yosef when he wants to return home, Yaakov has the opportunity, in response to Lavan’s preference that he stay - for his presence has been good for Lavan, to pick how he will build his own wealth. Yaakov acknowledges, and repeats what Lavan said, that God has been good to Lavan with Yaakov’s presence, and now Yaakov asks וְעַתָּ֗ה מָתַ֛י אֶֽעֱשֶׂ֥ה גַם־אָנֹכִ֖י לְבֵיתִֽי. And now, when will I build for my own household?

 Lavan asks, מה אתן לך (what shall I give you?), and Yaakov’s answer is “I don’t want to be on salary. I want a commission.” And then he defines the commission based on criteria that are acceptable to Lavan. Yaakov will care for Lavan’s white sheep, and his dark goats, and whatever is born that has spots, speckles, rings in the pattern of their skin or wool – that will belong to Yaakov going forward. Anything that is the same single color as its parents will belong to Lavan. 

 Let’s use an example in the human realm to illustrate. Imagine if two slaves originally from India were to have children, and a deal is made by the new son in law of the master of the house with his father in law that any children they have that will be Chinese would belong to the younger man, while all of their Indian children would of course belong to the father-in-law. It’s a no brainer. Of course the young man would be expected to get little to nothing. Perhaps a rare genetic mutation will produce a Chinese child, on the off chance that an ancestor way back was somehow Chinese. But really, the one who will be getting the most out of this is the master of the house. Clearly. 

 But Yaakov is not dealing in the realm of the natural order of the world. Whether he was expecting God to help him, or whether he had learned over time about animals in heat and what it means for them to see images that have an impact on their offspring… the Torah’s depiction of what happens in the next six years is summarized in the last verse of chapter 30 - וַיִּפְרֹ֥ץ הָאִ֖ישׁ מְאֹ֣ד מְאֹ֑ד וַֽיְהִי־לוֹ֙ צֹ֣אן רַבּ֔וֹת וּשְׁפָחוֹת֙ וַעֲבָדִ֔ים וּגְמַלִּ֖ים וַחֲמֹרִֽים: The man’s [wealth] multiplied very much, and he had many sheep, maids, servants, camels and doneys.

 Rabb Moshe Shternbuch argued that there was no trick here. The whole thing was ordained by heaven. Yaakov later explains this to his wives based on the dreams he had, as he describes how Lavan changed the terms all the time. In a nutshell, whatever your father would say would be my wages – that is what was born on most of the sheep. אִם־כֹּ֣ה יֹאמַ֗ר נְקֻדִּים֙ יִהְיֶ֣ה שְׂכָרֶ֔ךָ וְיָלְד֥וּ כָל־הַצֹּ֖אן נְקֻדִּ֑ים וְאִם־כֹּ֣ה יֹאמַ֗ר עֲקֻדִּים֙ יִהְיֶ֣ה שְׂכָרֶ֔ךָ וְיָלְד֥וּ כָל־הַצֹּ֖אן עֲקֻדִּֽים: In other words (verse 9) God orchestrated all of your father’s flock turning over into my own hands.

 A different perspective is offered by R Shlomo Leib of Lentschna based on a statement in Hoshanos on Hoshana Rabba – למען מיחם מקלות בשקתות המים הושענא הושיעה נא – that even a man of truth such as Yaakov, stuck in Lavan’s house for 20 years, is going to resort to certain tricks that he picked up in such an environment – what are we to do if after living 2000 years amongst the nations we’ve picked up a few tricks of survival of our own which are not on the up and up?

 I want to make clear that being dishonest is not OK. But using shtick that is not illegal but may border on some rules of ethics may be excusable in an environment when if you don’t swim with the fishes you drown. In other words if the words to the judge are “it’s not illegal and everyone else is doing it” – the Jew has an excuse for why he is doing something that doesn’t pass the smell test according to those who want to redefine the smell test. 

 And yet Radak posits that Yaakov didn’t do this in the first year. His original “wages” were the sheep that were these anomalies, the few that were already spotted and speckled, and it was only those that Yaakov made sure for them to mate during the year, and to allow Lavan’s sheep, that he tended to during this time, to mate normally as well, so everything would seem to be going in Lavan’s favor. He quotes his father who gave this explanation: כי רבים תמהים על יעקב אבינו שהיה צדיק איך היה עושה דבר רמאות בצאן לבן להרבות חלקו (“for many wonder about Yaakov Avinu, the righteous, how he could do this trickery with Lavan’s sheep so that he would profit?!”): So his argument is that he didn’t resort to trickery. (Daas Zekenim adds that Lavan accepted the terms and changed them over and over. Yaakov was forced to respond in kind ).

 Which is also the route that Ramban takes in that Yaakov only did this in one season of the year – in Nissan, when the stronger sheep are in heat, versus in Tishrei, when the not as strong sheep are in heat. Ramban also notes that despite his efforts to keep things normal, God orchestrated that most of the sheep born in the first year, did in fact have the spots, etc that allowed them to grow in the ownership of Yaakov. 

 Putting the different ideas together, Rabbenu Bachaye says this was a דבר חכמה וסוד הטבע מעורב בנס – wisdom and the uncovering of the secrets of nature coupled with a miracle) because the rods he put logically makes sense, but it was absolutely a miracle that the female animals didn’t give birth to animals that looked like them. And once again, even if you believe the rods could work in a natural way, that it worked for ALL of the animals can only be understood if one believes in miracles. ALL the sheep were looking in the same direction? ALL the sheep were PROCESSING the same thing? ALL the sheep were thus “influenced” to have these babies this way?

 Yaakov says it clearly. ואלהי אבי היה עמדי, “The God of my father was with me.” 

 And I think that is the most important takeaway we can have when it comes to parnassah in general.

 Sure, some people inherit wealth. Some people are very talented and skilled. Some are better with money than others. Some people seem to have a lot of luck.

 But the bottom line is that Yaakov Avinu was showing us, you have to put in your hishtadlus. And if all works right, God will carry you the rest of the way. 

 The most devout people know this. And particularly the ones who seem to know best what to do with their material success, sharing it with others to better mankind, they understand that their success is because God is with them. 

 Yaakov may have gotten the greatest blessing in the world from his father. But he didn’t rely on it alone. He worked like a slave to be successful. And he even aimed to prove to Eisav that his wealth is not from a blessing from his father, but is because עם לבן גרתי (I lived with Lavan – and in that space I developed this wealth), as he’ll announce next week. And I worked hard in my work as much as I worked hard on my relationship with God. 

 And it is these two things which make for the most fulfilled life. Some people do them simultaneously – they work on their relationship with God while working hard to support their family.

 And some work hard to support their family so they can enjoy retirement. And hopefully when they are retired, they are working hard on their relationship with God, in a manner that may have been somewhat neglected in earlier years.

 Yaakov’s wealth may have come from sheep. But for us, our relationship with God shouldn’t be sheepish. Our own relationship with God grows through the obvious methods of Torah and Tefillah, but also in the Chesed that we do and achieve in our imitation of God who is the definition of Rachamim and the definition of Chesed. When we make room in our hearts for others, especially if we might see them as odd, or if they don’t fit in the box we might imagine most people fall into, we are embracing God’s children, and being כרחם אב על בנים.

 We learn from Biblical shepherds how to look out for even the weakest sheep, and to show mercy to them even under challenging conditions and circumstances. Yaakov growing his wealth through sheep is a metaphor for expanding our relationship with God, not thinking we are owed anything by anyone, and, if we play our cards right, being blessed by God with the blessings He sees us as deserving. May we be so deserving and so blessed.

No comments:

Post a Comment