Friday, August 23, 2024

A Simple Matter

Parshat Eikev

In the “Otzar Chaim” anthology of Divrei Torah, Rabbi Tzukerman (the editor) records a story of a certain man who was aiming to get his certification to be a recognized shochet, so he would be recognized as someone who could slaughter animals for the kosher consumer. The rabbi he went to was a righteous and punctilious man, who would not simply offer his consent to anyone who came his way, but would only put his stamp of approval on a person he felt met all the qualifications, knew all the laws, etc. 

 After several rounds of inadequate tests and not-to-snuff-shechitahs (in the good rabbi’s opinion), the candidate frustratingly asked if the rabbi could hurry up and fulfill his request for the certification. The rabbi hinted to him “Nu, and what about the small matter?” The candidate thought he understood and brought the rabbi a small donation. 

Friday, August 16, 2024

Does Our Life Have a Purpose? Depends on How You Look At It

Parshat Va'Etchanan 

by Rabbi Avi Billet

The methodology behind coming up with each topic for a weekly Dvar Torah is a study unto itself. Sometimes the thought is driven by something the writer really wants to say – the message is there, and it’s just a question of attaching it to a verse in the Parsha. Sometimes the writer has a burning question that is personally troubling, so answering that conundrum becomes the driving force behind the research. Sometimes a cursory reading through Midrash will beg the question “what is this telling us?” or “what does this really mean?” and will lead the thought in a different direction. 

 And sometimes one comes across a troubling passage and has a need to “think aloud” but on paper. 

 The following is of the latter variety. 

Friday, August 9, 2024

Timeliness and a Different Kind of Rebuke

Parshat Devarim

by Rabbi Avi Billet

The parsha begins by setting the time and stage for Moshe’s goodbye speech to the Children of Israel, giving us many geographical coordinates while noting that it’s the beginning of the 11th month. The Sifrei (Midrash on Devarim) tells us that “This teaches that Moshe waited to rebuke them until close to the time of his death. He learned this tactic from Yaakov Avinu who gave rebuke to his own children just before he died. Yaakov did this so he wouldn’t have to rebuke more than once. And also, if his words were negative, it would prevent people from having to look him in the face and be embarrassed, since he wouldn’t be around for very long after the rebuke was given.” 

What’s the difference on the timing? What if he would choose to only rebuke once, thinking “I’ve said my piece, I don’t need to repeat it, even though the opportunity may present itself again.” Besides, what’s the benefit anyway, if in the end of the day they won’t listen? 

Monday, August 5, 2024

Nine Days Rules To Wean us INTO Mourning

 Here is a link to the summary of Nine Days rules I shared 6 years ago. It was for a year in which Tisha B'Av was observed on Sunday. [It is a little more comprehensive than what is presented this year, below. But what is below reflects on when Tisha B'Av is observed on a Tuesday - as it is this year.]


Summary of Laws of the Nine Days 

 When Rosh Chodesh Av begins this Sunday night (8/4) (Rosh Chodesh is Sunday night and Monday), the days which follow - through Tisha B’Av - are observed as a time of mourning. Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik compared the mourning of these 9 days to the style of mourning for a Shloshim period – the 30 days following the death of a loved one. As such, the mourning practices of this period are intended to be a little stricter than the days which began on 17 Tammuz, to help us be more prepared for the ultimate day of mourning, Tisha B’Av. 

Friday, August 2, 2024

Fighting the War With Midian - Instruction for Our Time?

As emphasized below, this is NOT to be taken as suggestions for strategy in Israel today. There are parallels in the way the enemy views to destroy Israel and the need to defend your people and even assert your strength. This is a reporting of how things were dealt with in the Torah's narrative, and observations of a few ways in which things are very different now.

Parshat Matot-Masei 

by Rabbi Avi Billet

 With the war in Israel intensifying on different fronts, some of the most important instruction from our Parsha seems rather timely, particularly concerning three specific topics. 

The first is about how to deal with the enemy that is bent on your destruction, in this case Midian. The Israelites were given very detailed instruction of how far they were to go to be sure Midian’s defeat was final. They were told which population demographics were to be killed and which were to be allowed to live. 

While I don’t suggest that this instruction was meant to be utilized beyond that specific war, please note the following theory, about the relevance of killing the young boys of Midian: https://arabbiwithoutacause.blogspot.com/2011/07/revenge-anything-but-sweet.html 

The second topic is the debate of universal conscription into the army. 

Those who are learning Mishnah Yomis recently learned the Mishnah which speaks of the t’nai kaful, the double edged condition made by the tribes of Gad and Reuven when negotiating for their tribes to be given land outside of Israel proper. Moshe’s initial response to them, perhaps not seeing their intentions completely, was “How can your brothers go out to fight while you remain behind?” (32:6) 

Their response was “We will build certain structures and infrastructure for our families, but then we will go out to war, not returning until all the land of Canaan has been captured and is in Jewish hands.” (32:16-17)

The point Moshe was driving home was that the responsibility to see to it that the land is in the hands of Am Yisrael rests on all members of Am Yisrael. No one can shirk their responsibility and say “I don’t live there.” Or “This is not my fight.” 

As in the previous example, one could argue that the instruction was for the original conquest and that that circumstance was unlikely to repeat itself in the future. 

One of the more relevant arguments I have heard against full conscription for all takes two parts: 1. The army lends itself to people who are “frum” but perhaps on the fences of finding out their true self to find a certain kind of individual freedom while in the military, leading to the dropping of observance, and 2. “If we have to be in the army for three years, then everyone in the army should have to be in yeshiva for 3 years.” [Those who are not in the ‘religious camp’ would likely never agree to this.] 

It’s not an answer to the larger question- and perhaps it’s not my place to opine. But at least it’s a perspective that some are advancing emphasizing the value of Torah, and the ease through which one can be led to drop one’s adherence to Torah (not necessarily automatic, or even by design… but the numbers are not insignificant).

Obviously there are ways to go through the army with a cohesive unit, such as those who study in Hesder, or those who go through a Mechina program, and have a much more supported Army experience that jibes with religious values. So these are generalizations, not necessary reflective of everyone’s experience. But there is a necessary balance that promotes service while supporting Jewish commitment in a way that is certainly not “automatic” when in an army setting. 

And this says nothing about the role Diaspora Jewry should undertake – do our children all need to serve in the IDF, so that our brothers and sisters in Israel not carry the burden alone? 

The third topic is about what it means to have enemies planted within your borders. 33:55 makes the case to the Bnei Yisrael that if you don’t rid yourselves of the enemies in the land, it will come back to haunt you in the most significant ways - “Then those whom you leave over will be as spikes in your eyes and thorns in your sides, and they will harass you in the land in which you settle.” 

 This is not to suggest any particular strategy for the IDF, or the State of Israel, going forward. But it does inform us that the Biblical Israelites faced similar problems, and found a way to do what needed to be done, albeit imperfectly, for the sake of the nation. [One can argue that Israel, imperfect as it is, has found a way with the rainbow of ethnicities in Israel… The problem remains with the enemy at the edge of its borders, as well as their sympathizers who live within its borders.] 

May all those directly involved find a path forward for everyone, balancing sensitivities with a sense of responsibility, so the Jewish people in Israel, and by extension abroad, can feel we are doing our part for the sake of bringing about full sovereignty and peace for the Jewish people in the Holy Land.

Friday, July 26, 2024

Different Kinds of Rushing to Judge

Parshat Pinchas

by Rabbi Avi Billet

The first Brisker Rov, Rabbi Yushe Ber Soloveitchik (for whom the 20th century Rabbi Joseph Soloveitchik – his great grandson – was named) asked a simple question. 

 When one studies the narratives of the Torah, there are four times when a case comes before Moshe where he has to turn to God for the halakhic answer*. These times are Pesach Sheni (Bamidbar 9), the daughters of Tzlafchad (Bamidbar 27), the blasphemer (Vayikra 24), and the wood gatherer on Shabbos (Bamidbar 15). It is interesting to note that there is debate as to the chronological order of these events, based on an assumption that the Torah is not automatically presented to us on chronological order and because sometimes tales are presented to us in the narrative thematically, connected to tales that are related to one another in their content, message or theme, but not based on their chronology. 

 Rabbi Soloveitchik asked, how is it that for two of these cases, Moshe essentially turned to God for an immediate answer, and in two of them he waited for a few days until God decided to give him the answer that had been evading him? Shouldn't he be looking for resolution as soon as possible in all cases?

He answers that there are two very different things going on in the cases for which Moshe sought an immediate answer than the ones that ended up following a 3-day waiting period. 

 In the cases of Tzlafchad’s daughters and those looking to bring the Korban Pesach, what drove them was a zeal to fulfill mitzvos. The daughters of Tzlafchad had a desire to live in and love the land of Canaan (Eretz Yisrael), and the Korban Pesach people did not want to miss out on this special mitzvah, which only comes around once a year. In these cases, Moshe was inspired to get an answer for them right away. 

 The other two cases involved someone who had done something against the Torah’s rules, and Moshe knew their repercussion would be death – it was just a question of which form of Misas Beis Din would be applicable. 

 Since in the cases of Tzlafchad’s daighters and Korban Pesach they were zerizin who were trying to be makdimin l’mitzvos, doing what they could to rush to fulfill a mitzvah properly, Moshe felt compelled to get them an answer as soon as possible. In the other two cases, Moshe felt no need to rush since rushing a “punishment” would only hasten their deaths. There is no mitzvah to rush something like that. He was happy to wait until God pronounced the judgment for each case in question. 

 An important lesson can be taken from this teaching as to how we relate to our fellow man. Motivation in actions should compel us to be helpful to others when appropriate and should, in other cases, cause us to wish to delay confrontation. Perhaps the delay may even give us the opportunity to be dan kl’kaf zechus (to judge favorably) if we might not have done so otherwise. 

 In all cases described, Moshe was unsure of the path forward, but he saw what was driving the people when the case came before him, and what seemed to be the most equitable solution. In the cases of Pesach and daughters, seeing them for who they were and what brought them to him (of their own accord) rather than their being brought to him for something they had done surely stood in their favor, as they wanted a particular outcome based on what they were experiencing. In both cases, the solution offered to them was quite equitable, reasonable, and fair. 

 I recall learning portions of Choshen Mishpat with Rabbi Moshe Tendler Z”L, and being rather surprised at some of the ways in which the Shulchan Arukh paints litigants in a court room as being understanding, submissive, following the rules, etc. I noted to Rabbi Tendler something to the effect of “I don’t see people conducting themselves this way, certainly not in a secular court, and in many cases not even when dealing with a Bet Din.” The way the Shulchah Arukh describes judges and the respect people are to have for the judges and their judgment seemed a little out to lunch, since it is rather atypical for someone who “loses” in court to be joyous and not to harbor ill will towards the co-litigant or the judges. And Rabbi Tendler told me, “The Shulchan Arukh assumes that Jewish people want to do the right thing and want to conduct themselves in a manner that is dictated by halakha.” 

There is certainly a lot of truth to that in general, as people are careful to fulfill many aspects of ritual correctly. But I don’t know if it is true in practice when it comes to those who are on the losing side of a financial case in court. Many people may find it very difficult to walk away from losing, b’simcha, seeing the other litigant and the judges in a positive light. 

 And yet this is also the challenge that Moshe is sending us in demonstrating how to conduct oneself when one is unsure. When motivations are pure – seek for resolution ASAP. When motivations are not 100% pure, delay a little. Seek for compromise, seek to find a way that makes everyone happy, or at the very least content that a proper process was gone through to get to resolution. Ultimately, when someone is going to suffer, and suffering is something we’d like to delay as much as possible, we want to be aware of that outcome as a possibility and act with sensitivity to that reality.

May disputes, and clarifications in halakha, be met with proper resolution in a timely fashion, hopefully with all parties walking away feeling that justice was served and the word of God was followed. 
 ___________ 
* There are other times when people point out a law to Moshe that he seems to have forgotten. For example, Aharon notes to Moshe that his sons should not be eating meat before their brothers are buried (Vayikra 10); the Rabbis tell us that Pinchas came along and killed Zimri when Moshe was standing around not knowing what to do (Bamidbar 24).

Friday, July 19, 2024

I Can’t Do It

Parshat Balak

by Rabbi Avi Billet 

The parsha is replete with exchanges and dialogue between Balak, King of Moab, and Bilaam, necromancer. At first they communicate through emissaries, and later on they meet in person, carrying on several conversations aimed at Bilaam doing his best to curse the Jewish people. 

 To Bilaam’s credit (though some will suggest it’s an example of Bilaam showing off), Bilaam does declare that “I can not violate the word of God.” Put more succinctly, as he tells both emissaries and Balak personally, “Even if Balak gives me his entire palace filled silver and gold, I still can not violate the word of God for good or for bad on my own – what God tells me is what I will say.” 

 Balak is understandably upset by all this, particularly after the fact, and he tells Bilaam, “Go home! I said I would honor you, but God has made you unworthy of honor!” (24:11). 

Is Balak really “understandably” upset? After all, Bilaam did tell both sets of Balak’s emissaries and Balak in person that he could only say what God might allow him to say! It could be that Balak didn’t accept this excuse because Bilaam had a reputation that he could say or do whatever he wanted. Of course, that could mean that Bilaam’s reputation was based on how he dealt with other nations. The fact that Israel is a different kind of entity, who benefit from a unique form of Divine Protection, seems to be lost on Balak in his mis-understanding Bilaam’s abilities. 

 But is that really the case? The whole reason why Balak hired Bilaam in the first place is because “Balak saw all that Israel had done to the Emorite” (22:2)! Why was he upset at what Bilaam said he couldn’t do, when that had been made clear to him from the get-go… God is on their side! 

Rabbi Baruch Halevi Epstein (in his Tosefes Bracha) explains that there are two motivations for a person to say “I can’t” do something. 

 One is a physical impossibility. I can’t lift a building with my bare hands. I can’t jump across a river. Examples of this kind of incapability appear in the Torah: the angel saw he couldn’t defeat Yaakov (Bereshis 32:26), the spies felt we can’t defeat the strong armies in Canaan (Bamidbar 13:31), etc. 

The other is not physically impossible, but is impossible because of one’s state of the mind or some other emotional preventative barrier, such as it being a commandment. For example: Yosef’s brothers could not speak with him peaceably (Bereshis 37:4), the Egyptians couldn’t eat with the Israelites (Bereshits 43:32), you can’t eat Maaser Sheni at your home as it needs to be eaten in Jerusalem (Devarim 12:17); you can’t neglect a lost object (Devarim 22:3), etc. 

 In this latter category of “can’t,” a feeling might be that if some other factor is thrown into the mix, the person may be able to “get over” the inability and do that which they feel incapable of doing at this time (unless, obviously, bound by a mitzvah). In the former category, no amount of incentive will help a person do that which a person is physically incapable of doing. Other than Superman, no one, for example, could leap tall buildings in a single bound. Even for all the money in the world. 

 Rabbi Epstein suggests that Balak felt Bilaam’s declared inability of “I can not violate God’s word” was of the latter category. He felt Bilaam was not in the right frame of mind, and all he needed was a different perspective from which to view the Israelites, his intended target, which is why they changed mountaintops over and over, or he needed a promise of great honor or more money. Bilaam had to explain to him that money or honor were meaningless. They couldn’t change what Bilaam was capable of doing. His inability was of the former kind – he was physically incapable of saying words that God would not allow him to say. 

 Rabbi Epstein concludes comparing this situation to what Lavan (who many identify as an ancestor of Bilaam) said to Avraham’s servant: “We are unable to speak to you good or bad.” In Lavan’s case, the power of speech had been taken from him and his father to the point that they couldn’t even say good things. They were limited in the kinds of speech they could aim at Avraham’s servant, as per Yevamos 103b “Even the good of the wicked is bad for the righteous.” That is a cautionary reminder to be careful with whom we engage in dialogue. 

 The following illustration is meant to showcase a relatable example of “I can’t” with respect to non-kosher food, and is not looking to paint anyone in a bad light. My wife and I were recently in a mostly empty Kosher sushi restaurant, and the only other customers in the store were a non-Jewish Indian couple. (How they found a Kosher sushi place? I do not know). They were sitting at the counter in front of the sushi bar and talking with the workers behind the counter, one is Korean, the other an Orthodox Jew. They spoke of food they like, and the Indian gentleman (who came across as a secular Muslim) was talking about a new chain of restaurants opening that has Halal meat. And then he mentioned the best food place he’s ever been to. Demonstrating an awareness of the Jewish worker, he said, “but are you strictly Kosher?” The answer was “Yes.” 

 “Well, if you ever change, you gotta check this place out!” His wife gently indicated to her husband to drop it, “Stop it! He’s not changing! Leave him alone.” The guy was friendly though, and he said, “What? My relatives are Muslims. Some of them keep the rules. And others have changed and have decided that they do whatever they want! Maybe he will one day too!” Again his wife told him to drop it, and he did. But the Jewish worker said, “No. I’m not changing!” 

 He didn’t say “I can’t eat non-kosher” but nonetheless he was demonstrating his inability through fealty to the commandments of God. Certainly anyone can physically eat non-kosher should they choose to. But one can’t if one lives by the rules. 

There are times, however, when we say “I can’t do something,” but it’s not because of a physical incapability. We don’t want to do it. 

We don’t want to set more time for Torah study, we don’t want to turn off our phones when we are in shul or engaged in an activity that requires our undivided attention, we don’t want to be more careful with our diets, we don’t want to exercise, we don’t want to give of ourselves, we don’t want to have difficult conversations or talk to people with whom we disagree, we don’t want to give beyond what we think are our means, we don’t want to give compliments and go out of our way to make people feel comfortable or to make people feel appreciated or special, we don’t want to step out of our comfort zone and be helpful when it’s easier to relax or disappear. 

Bilaam’s excuse was legitimate. He knew his limitation was God-sent, and he was truthful and up-front about it. Balak was like the guy in the restaurant and believed that Bilaam could curse the Israelites if he truly wanted to (Bilaam wanted to!), and he couldn’t fathom that Bilaam’s speech in this regard was actually not in his control. 

 Where things are in our control, may we be blessed to do the things we say we can’t, when the barrier is really just our minds, sometimes laziness, and mostly a lack of desire to challenge ourselves to be and do better. We CAN lift ourselves up and bring more meaning to our existence through rising to the challenge of doing the things we’ve told ourselves we can’t do… because really, we can!