Tuesday, April 10, 2012

Cute Trivia Q

While looking at the Shmoneh Esreh, it occurred to me that most of the 19 blessings undergo some sort of change during the year. I am not referring to a "slightly different version" of such a text (such as "Vlamalshinim" v "V'laminim").

Question: How many of Shmoneh Esreh's blessings never undergo any kind of change during the year?

Answers welcome in the comments...

1 comment:

  1. Ho hum. No one chimed in. OK. The answer is "7".
    The first three blessings have a change during עשרת ימי תשובה
    The fourth blessing has a change on מוצאי שבת
    5, 6 and 7 have no changes (a blessing is added after #7 on fast days... but it is an added blessing - does not change #7) --- This accounts for 3
    The eight blessing (Refaeinu) has additions for the ill.
    The ninth blessing changes for a few months during the winter
    The tenth blessing has no changes --- This accounts for the fourth
    The eleventh blessing (Hashiva) has an עשרת ימי תשובה change
    The next two (V'lamalshinim and Al Hatzadikkim) have different גרסאות out there - but they do not have changes. --- This accounts for #s 5 and 6 in our count.
    Blessing # fourteen has an addition on Tisha B'Av
    The fifteenth blessing is our final unchanging one: את צמח --- this is #7.
    The sixteenth blessing is Shma Koleinu which has room for all kinds of interruptions, including ענינו on a fast day
    R'zeh (#17) includes Yaaleh V'yavo
    Modim (#18) has insertions for Hanukkah, Purim and עשרת ימי תשובה.
    Sim Shalom also has an insertion for עשרת ימי תשובה.

    ReplyDelete